Find me on facebook www.facebook.com/shamshad.haider https://www.youtube.com/shamshad14
Saturday, October 26, 2013
Brazil, China, Venezuela sharply critical of illegal drone strikes
NEW YORK: The US government has defended its use of drone strikes in Pakistan, Yemen and other countries in front of the UN, telling a chamber full of largely critical nations that in President Obama's view the deployment of unmanned aerial attacks against al-Qaida targets was "necessary, legal and just".
Representatives from a slew of nations, including Brazil, China and Venezuela, lined up to berate the Obama administration for its intensive use of drone strikes. But the US delegation told a plenary meeting of the general assembly in the UN building in New York the president had taken steps to introduce new guidance and standards, and to set out the legal rationale for unmanned weapons deployed in the fight against al-Qaida and affiliated threats.
The UN debate marked the first time that member nations have come together to discuss the rapidly expanding militarised use of remotely piloted aircraft and the fraught international legal issues that it raises. It came at the climax of 10 days in which the question of the legality of drones has caught the headlines, with the release of two UN reports that have sharply condemned aspects of the programmes.
The authors of the two reports addressed Friday's UN debate, beginning with Christof Heyns, the UN's special rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions. His study warned of the danger of proliferation of the un-piloted weapons among states and terrorist groups.
In his opening remarks to the UN debate, Heyns said "drones are here to stay". He argued that it was hard to make a case that unmanned aircraft were inherently illegal: "It is difficult to suggest that a weapon system is unlawful because a pilot is not on board."
But he added that drones were easy to deploy across international borders, often secretly. "So it is my view that although they are not illegal, they do pose a challenge, particularly as they are used often in secret, raising accountability issues."
The accountability theme was picked up by the second UN expert, Ben Emmerson, the special rapporteur on human rights and counter-terrorism. His ongoing investigation into lethal extra-territorial counter-terrorism operations has concluded that the 33 drone strikes that are known to have caused civilian casualties may have been carried out in violation of international law.
He told the assembled nations that lack of transparency was "the single greatest obstacle to an evaluation of the civilian impact of drone strikes and it's a challenge which makes it extremely difficult to assess claims of precision targeting objectively".
He urged delegates to consider whether an absolute ban was needed on secret deals cooked up between states for engagement in joint military actions.
Emmerson also underlined the state of chaos that exists in international law over drones: "Despite the proliferation of this technology, there remains a lack of consensus among international lawyers and between states on the core legal principles."
He added: "It's not the drone that is the problem. The problem is the lack of clarity under which it is lawful to deploy lethal force by drone."
The UK, one of three countries alongside the US and Israel that have attracted most attention for the use of unmanned assault aircraft, also tried to defend its military deployment of the technology. Emmerson's report points out that the UK government has reported only one incident involving civilian casualties: an RAF strike in March 2011 in Afghanistan in which four civilians were killed.
The UK mission attempted to defend its use of drones in military situations, telling the debate that the weapons systems were controlled by personnel on the ground and were therefore not "autonomous" or robotic – a status which would push them over into illegality in the opinions of most legal experts. The UK has no plans to replace controlled drones with autonomous weapons, the UN was told, while the engagement of unmanned planes within the RAF falls under exactly the same strict military rules as ordinary piloted fighter jets.
But several countries questioned the legality of the weapons. Venezuela called drones "flagrantly illegal" and said that by its accounting, 1,800 people had been casualties – only about 10% of whom were "targeted individuals". "This is like a collective punishment," Venezuela's representative said.
Brazil wondered where the line would be drawn in terms of potential targets for drone strikes. "In certain regions we might have sympathisers of terrorists – does that mean they become 'fair game' just because they sympathise with a particular cause, that they are legitimate targets of drone attacks, for yet another kill? This is uncharted waters."
China, which normally keeps to the sidelines of the most contentious international disputes, was driven to state that drones were a "blank space in international law, and this blank space is subject to abuse … We should respect the principles of UN charters, the sovereignty of states and the legitimate rights of the citizens of all countries."
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
- Jun 21 - Jun 28 (1)
- Jun 14 - Jun 21 (3)
- Jun 7 - Jun 14 (3)
- Mar 15 - Mar 22 (8)
- Mar 8 - Mar 15 (53)
- Mar 1 - Mar 8 (20)
- Feb 23 - Mar 1 (10)
- Feb 16 - Feb 23 (19)
- Feb 9 - Feb 16 (17)
- Feb 2 - Feb 9 (38)
- Jan 26 - Feb 2 (9)
- Jan 19 - Jan 26 (9)
- Jan 12 - Jan 19 (23)
- Jan 5 - Jan 12 (14)
- Dec 29 - Jan 5 (10)
- Dec 22 - Dec 29 (14)
- Dec 15 - Dec 22 (9)
- Dec 8 - Dec 15 (6)
- Dec 1 - Dec 8 (14)
- Nov 24 - Dec 1 (30)
- Nov 17 - Nov 24 (36)
- Nov 10 - Nov 17 (6)
- Nov 3 - Nov 10 (16)
- Oct 27 - Nov 3 (36)
- Oct 20 - Oct 27 (21)
- Oct 13 - Oct 20 (44)
- Oct 6 - Oct 13 (17)
- Sep 29 - Oct 6 (14)
- Sep 22 - Sep 29 (30)
- Sep 15 - Sep 22 (17)
- Sep 8 - Sep 15 (24)
- Sep 1 - Sep 8 (41)
- Aug 25 - Sep 1 (24)
- Aug 18 - Aug 25 (28)
- Aug 11 - Aug 18 (15)
- Aug 4 - Aug 11 (13)
- Jul 28 - Aug 4 (8)
- Jul 21 - Jul 28 (2)
- Jul 14 - Jul 21 (7)
- Jul 7 - Jul 14 (3)
- Jun 30 - Jul 7 (8)
- Jun 2 - Jun 9 (7)
- May 26 - Jun 2 (1)
- May 19 - May 26 (14)
- May 12 - May 19 (12)
- May 5 - May 12 (21)
- Apr 28 - May 5 (41)
- Apr 21 - Apr 28 (25)
- Apr 14 - Apr 21 (38)
- Apr 7 - Apr 14 (38)
- Mar 31 - Apr 7 (17)
- Mar 24 - Mar 31 (26)
- Mar 17 - Mar 24 (12)
- Mar 10 - Mar 17 (26)
- Mar 3 - Mar 10 (10)
- Feb 24 - Mar 3 (39)
- Feb 17 - Feb 24 (19)
- Feb 10 - Feb 17 (23)
- Feb 3 - Feb 10 (44)
- Jan 27 - Feb 3 (15)
- Jan 20 - Jan 27 (25)
- Jan 13 - Jan 20 (26)
- Jan 6 - Jan 13 (4)
- Dec 30 - Jan 6 (12)
- Dec 23 - Dec 30 (22)
- Dec 16 - Dec 23 (1)
- Dec 9 - Dec 16 (12)
- Dec 2 - Dec 9 (32)
- Nov 25 - Dec 2 (40)
- Nov 18 - Nov 25 (24)
- Nov 11 - Nov 18 (48)
- Nov 4 - Nov 11 (20)
- Oct 28 - Nov 4 (29)
- Oct 21 - Oct 28 (39)
- Oct 14 - Oct 21 (32)
- Oct 7 - Oct 14 (41)
- Sep 30 - Oct 7 (25)
- Sep 23 - Sep 30 (26)
- Sep 16 - Sep 23 (34)
- Sep 9 - Sep 16 (29)
- Sep 2 - Sep 9 (40)
- Aug 26 - Sep 2 (20)
- Aug 19 - Aug 26 (10)
- Aug 12 - Aug 19 (21)
- Aug 5 - Aug 12 (46)
- Jul 29 - Aug 5 (10)
- Jul 22 - Jul 29 (2)
- Jul 15 - Jul 22 (8)
- Jul 8 - Jul 15 (13)
- Jul 1 - Jul 8 (16)
- Jun 24 - Jul 1 (24)
- Jun 17 - Jun 24 (6)
- Jun 10 - Jun 17 (38)
- Jun 3 - Jun 10 (46)
- May 27 - Jun 3 (30)
- May 20 - May 27 (17)
- May 13 - May 20 (29)
- May 6 - May 13 (10)
- Apr 29 - May 6 (31)
- Apr 22 - Apr 29 (50)
- Apr 15 - Apr 22 (16)
- Apr 8 - Apr 15 (37)
- Apr 1 - Apr 8 (48)
- Mar 25 - Apr 1 (36)
- Mar 18 - Mar 25 (40)
- Mar 11 - Mar 18 (38)
- Mar 4 - Mar 11 (14)
- Feb 25 - Mar 4 (34)
- Feb 18 - Feb 25 (34)
- Feb 11 - Feb 18 (15)
- Feb 4 - Feb 11 (46)
- Jan 28 - Feb 4 (16)
- Jan 21 - Jan 28 (10)
- Jan 14 - Jan 21 (11)
- Jan 7 - Jan 14 (24)
- Dec 31 - Jan 7 (10)
- Dec 24 - Dec 31 (11)
- Dec 17 - Dec 24 (21)
- Dec 10 - Dec 17 (27)
- Dec 3 - Dec 10 (19)
- Nov 26 - Dec 3 (22)
- Nov 19 - Nov 26 (18)
- Nov 12 - Nov 19 (30)
- Nov 5 - Nov 12 (54)
- Oct 29 - Nov 5 (47)
- Oct 22 - Oct 29 (28)
- Oct 15 - Oct 22 (45)
- Oct 8 - Oct 15 (41)
- Oct 1 - Oct 8 (38)
- Sep 24 - Oct 1 (40)
- Sep 17 - Sep 24 (99)
- Sep 10 - Sep 17 (18)
- Sep 3 - Sep 10 (9)
- Aug 27 - Sep 3 (26)
- Aug 20 - Aug 27 (28)
- Aug 13 - Aug 20 (19)
- Aug 6 - Aug 13 (41)
- Jul 30 - Aug 6 (4)
- Jul 16 - Jul 23 (22)
- Jul 9 - Jul 16 (23)
- Jul 2 - Jul 9 (9)
- Jun 25 - Jul 2 (4)
- Jun 18 - Jun 25 (10)
- Jun 11 - Jun 18 (13)
- Jun 4 - Jun 11 (40)
- May 21 - May 28 (31)
- May 14 - May 21 (41)
- May 7 - May 14 (34)
- Apr 30 - May 7 (33)
- Apr 23 - Apr 30 (32)
- Apr 16 - Apr 23 (38)
- Apr 9 - Apr 16 (47)
- Apr 2 - Apr 9 (19)
- Mar 26 - Apr 2 (37)
- Mar 19 - Mar 26 (20)
- Mar 12 - Mar 19 (32)
- Mar 5 - Mar 12 (32)
- Feb 26 - Mar 5 (26)
- Feb 19 - Feb 26 (63)
- Feb 12 - Feb 19 (20)
- Feb 5 - Feb 12 (2)
- Jan 29 - Feb 5 (16)
- Jan 22 - Jan 29 (24)
- Jan 15 - Jan 22 (31)
- Jan 8 - Jan 15 (20)
- Jan 1 - Jan 8 (11)
- Dec 25 - Jan 1 (30)
- Dec 18 - Dec 25 (48)
- Dec 11 - Dec 18 (44)
- Dec 4 - Dec 11 (74)
- Nov 27 - Dec 4 (50)
- Nov 20 - Nov 27 (39)
- Nov 13 - Nov 20 (73)
- Nov 6 - Nov 13 (51)
- Oct 30 - Nov 6 (56)
- Oct 23 - Oct 30 (33)
- Oct 16 - Oct 23 (52)
- Oct 9 - Oct 16 (70)
- Oct 2 - Oct 9 (56)
- Sep 25 - Oct 2 (66)
- Sep 18 - Sep 25 (52)
- Sep 11 - Sep 18 (21)
- Sep 4 - Sep 11 (44)
- Aug 28 - Sep 4 (25)
- Aug 21 - Aug 28 (27)
- Aug 14 - Aug 21 (27)
- Aug 7 - Aug 14 (43)
- Jul 31 - Aug 7 (24)
- Jul 24 - Jul 31 (24)
- Jul 17 - Jul 24 (2)
- Jul 10 - Jul 17 (6)
- Jul 3 - Jul 10 (23)
- Jun 26 - Jul 3 (38)
- Jun 19 - Jun 26 (14)
- Jun 12 - Jun 19 (14)
- Jun 5 - Jun 12 (24)
- May 29 - Jun 5 (29)
- May 22 - May 29 (69)
- May 15 - May 22 (81)
- May 8 - May 15 (35)
- May 1 - May 8 (21)
- Apr 24 - May 1 (31)
- Apr 17 - Apr 24 (25)
- Apr 10 - Apr 17 (23)
- Apr 3 - Apr 10 (38)
- Mar 27 - Apr 3 (50)
- Mar 20 - Mar 27 (7)
- Mar 13 - Mar 20 (41)
- Mar 6 - Mar 13 (24)
- Feb 28 - Mar 6 (18)
- Feb 21 - Feb 28 (20)
- Feb 14 - Feb 21 (1)
- Feb 7 - Feb 14 (51)
- Jan 31 - Feb 7 (30)
- Jan 24 - Jan 31 (24)
- Jan 17 - Jan 24 (5)
- Jan 10 - Jan 17 (17)
- Jan 3 - Jan 10 (36)
- Dec 27 - Jan 3 (23)
- Dec 20 - Dec 27 (16)
- Dec 13 - Dec 20 (39)
- Dec 6 - Dec 13 (37)
- Nov 29 - Dec 6 (48)
- Nov 22 - Nov 29 (42)
- Nov 15 - Nov 22 (29)
- Nov 8 - Nov 15 (17)
- Nov 1 - Nov 8 (11)
- Oct 25 - Nov 1 (27)
- Oct 18 - Oct 25 (7)
- Oct 11 - Oct 18 (26)
- Oct 4 - Oct 11 (54)
- Sep 27 - Oct 4 (21)
- Sep 20 - Sep 27 (63)
- Sep 13 - Sep 20 (25)
- Sep 6 - Sep 13 (16)
- Aug 30 - Sep 6 (11)
- Aug 23 - Aug 30 (12)
- Aug 16 - Aug 23 (11)
- Aug 9 - Aug 16 (17)
- Aug 2 - Aug 9 (37)
- Jul 26 - Aug 2 (16)
- Jul 19 - Jul 26 (10)
- Jul 5 - Jul 12 (38)
- Jun 28 - Jul 5 (20)
- Jun 21 - Jun 28 (9)
- Jun 14 - Jun 21 (24)
- Jun 7 - Jun 14 (60)
- May 31 - Jun 7 (69)
- May 24 - May 31 (97)
- May 17 - May 24 (35)
- May 10 - May 17 (28)
- May 3 - May 10 (42)
- Apr 26 - May 3 (24)
- Apr 19 - Apr 26 (2)
- Apr 12 - Apr 19 (16)
- Apr 5 - Apr 12 (31)
- Mar 29 - Apr 5 (1)
- Sep 21 - Sep 28 (1)
- Aug 17 - Aug 24 (2)
- Aug 10 - Aug 17 (130)
- Aug 3 - Aug 10 (220)
- Jul 27 - Aug 3 (170)
- Jul 13 - Jul 20 (5)
- Jul 6 - Jul 13 (149)
- Jun 29 - Jul 6 (171)
- Jun 22 - Jun 29 (231)
- Jun 15 - Jun 22 (153)
- Jun 8 - Jun 15 (133)
- Jun 1 - Jun 8 (102)
- May 25 - Jun 1 (140)
- May 18 - May 25 (171)
- May 11 - May 18 (155)
- May 4 - May 11 (205)
- Apr 27 - May 4 (220)
- Apr 20 - Apr 27 (155)
- Apr 13 - Apr 20 (201)
- Apr 6 - Apr 13 (218)
- Mar 30 - Apr 6 (209)
- Mar 23 - Mar 30 (248)
- Mar 16 - Mar 23 (255)
- Mar 9 - Mar 16 (272)
- Mar 2 - Mar 9 (340)
- Feb 23 - Mar 2 (311)
- Feb 16 - Feb 23 (237)
- Feb 9 - Feb 16 (229)
- Feb 2 - Feb 9 (98)
- Jan 26 - Feb 2 (91)
- Jan 19 - Jan 26 (14)
- Jan 12 - Jan 19 (82)
- Jan 5 - Jan 12 (46)
- Dec 22 - Dec 29 (95)
- Dec 15 - Dec 22 (7)
- Dec 8 - Dec 15 (78)
- Dec 1 - Dec 8 (33)
- Nov 24 - Dec 1 (40)
- Nov 17 - Nov 24 (61)
- Nov 10 - Nov 17 (14)
- Oct 27 - Nov 3 (42)
- Oct 20 - Oct 27 (238)
- Oct 13 - Oct 20 (269)
- Oct 6 - Oct 13 (284)
- Sep 29 - Oct 6 (204)
- Sep 22 - Sep 29 (220)
- Sep 15 - Sep 22 (257)
- Sep 8 - Sep 15 (164)
No comments:
Post a Comment